Year 12/Operations/Practice cardsBack to School

Mrs Perkins home/Business Studies

OPS-I8  |  INFLUENCES

Corporate social responsibility - the difference between legal compliance and ethical responsibility

Outcomes: H3, H4  |  Also practises OPS-L4: explain why corporate social responsibility is a key concern in operations management

Do A Quick Check first. Then choose one of B, C or D. Write your answers in your book or note guide.

A  Quick Check

Identify  |  tap an answer for instant feedback

1. Legal compliance means:

2. Ethical responsibility means:

3. Checking overseas factories for forced labour when not legally required is an example of:

4. Corporate social responsibility (CSR) is:

B  Short Answer

Distinguish, Explain

1. Distinguish between legal compliance and ethical responsibility. (3 marks)

Write your answer in your book first. Then open the marking guide and mark it yourself.

Show the marking guide
MarksWhat it looks like
3Clear, accurate answer using an example or correct terms
2Mostly accurate, limited detail
1Some relevant information

Answers could include:

  • Legal compliance: meeting the minimum standards set by law
  • Ethical responsibility: voluntarily doing what is right, beyond the law
  • Example showing the difference

2. Explain why corporate social responsibility is a key concern in operations management. (5 marks)

Write your answer in your book first. Then open the marking guide and mark it yourself.

Show the marking guide
MarksWhat it looks like
5Thorough cause and effect, using an actual business
3-4Sound answer with some cause and effect
2Describes with little explanation
1Some relevant information

Answers could include:

  • Operations uses the most resources and has the biggest impact on workers, communities and the environment
  • Supply chain ethics (labour conditions, sourcing) sit within operations
  • Reputation and customer trust depend on how products are made
  • Investor and regulator pressure
  • Example of a business

C  Mini Business Report

Recommend  |  Outcomes H8, H9

Urban Threads is an Australian fashion label. A news story claims a factory it uses overseas pays very low wages and has unsafe conditions. Urban Threads has broken no Australian law, but sales have dropped 15% since the story ran.

Task: Recommend how Urban Threads should respond, using the difference between legal compliance and ethical responsibility.

About 250 words, written as a business report. Headings: Introduction / Current situation / Recommendations / Conclusion.

Check your report: a high-level response would include
  • Explains that it is legally compliant but not meeting ethical expectations
  • Recommends supplier audits, a supplier code of conduct and transparency (publishing factory lists)
  • Recommends working with the factory to improve conditions, or changing suppliers
  • Weighs the extra cost against the reputation and sales benefit

D  Case Study Collector

Analyse  |  Outcome H7

Business: Nike

Research and add to your Operations Case Study Bank:

  • What labour problems Nike faced in its supply chain in the 1990s
  • One change Nike made, with source and date
  • Whether this was legal compliance or ethical responsibility
  • How the issue affected its operations

Use a reliable source from the last 3 years where you can. Record the source name and date.

Check your entry: what to look for
  • Sweatshop criticism of the 1990s
  • Responses such as factory lists, codes of conduct, audits
  • Correct classification as ethical responsibility (beyond the law)