Year 12/Operations/Practice cardsBack to School

Mrs Perkins home/Business Studies

OPS-S4  |  OPERATIONS STRATEGIES

Outsourcing - advantages and disadvantages

Outcomes: H2, H5

Do A Quick Check first. Then choose one of B, C or D. Write your answers in your book or note guide.

A  Quick Check

Identify  |  tap an answer for instant feedback

1. Outsourcing is:

2. An advantage of outsourcing is:

3. A disadvantage of outsourcing is:

4. A business is most likely to outsource:

B  Short Answer

Outline, Explain

1. Outline ONE advantage and ONE disadvantage of outsourcing. (4 marks)

Write your answer in your book first. Then open the marking guide and mark it yourself.

Show the marking guide
MarksWhat it looks like
4Clear cause and effect, with a relevant example
3Sound answer, less detail or no example
2Describes with little explanation
1Some relevant information

Answers could include:

  • Advantage: lower costs, specialist skills, focus on core business, flexibility
  • Brief explanation of the advantage
  • Disadvantage: loss of control, quality risk, reputation, job losses, hidden costs
  • Brief explanation of the disadvantage

2. Explain why a business might outsource some operations but keep others in-house. (4 marks)

Write your answer in your book first. Then open the marking guide and mark it yourself.

Show the marking guide
MarksWhat it looks like
4Clear cause and effect, with a relevant example
3Sound answer, less detail or no example
2Describes with little explanation
1Some relevant information

Answers could include:

  • Core activities create competitive advantage, so they are kept in-house
  • Non-core activities can be done better or cheaper by specialists
  • Control and quality risk is lower for non-core activities
  • Example

C  Mini Business Report

Recommend  |  Outcomes H8, H9

Clearwater Pools builds pools on the Central Coast. It does its own design, digging, tiling and accounts. The accounts are often wrong, and tiling is slow because its two tilers are overworked.

Task: Recommend which operations Clearwater Pools should outsource, and which it should keep in-house.

About 250 words, written as a business report. Headings: Introduction / Current situation / Recommendations / Conclusion.

Check your report: a high-level response would include
  • Identifies core (design, building) and non-core (accounts) activities
  • Recommends outsourcing accounts and possibly some tiling to contractors
  • Recommends keeping design in-house as a source of advantage
  • Notes risks (quality, control) and how to manage them (contracts, checks)

D  Case Study Collector

Analyse  |  Outcome H7

Business: Qantas (ground handling)

Research and add to your Operations Case Study Bank:

  • What Qantas outsourced in 2020
  • What the courts decided, with source and date
  • One advantage Qantas expected
  • The disadvantages that followed

Use a reliable source from the last 3 years where you can. Record the source name and date.

Check your entry: what to look for
  • About 1,700 ground handling jobs outsourced
  • High Court ruling in 2023 that it was unlawful
  • Balanced judgement of advantages and disadvantages