Mrs Perkins home/Stage 4 Geography
Stage 4 Geography › Interconnections and Trade › Lesson 24
Labels, safety agreements and brand report cards all promise a fairer t-shirt. Find out how to judge which ones actually work.
Today you test three real strategies for managing the cotton t-shirt: Fairtrade cotton (a certification label), the International Accord (a legally binding safety agreement for garment factories) and the Ethical Fashion Report (a guide that grades fashion brands). You look at what each one does, the evidence behind it and its catch, then compare that evidence with a peer-reviewed study of palm oil certification.
This matters because a promise is not proof. To evaluate a strategy you need evidence, and you need to notice who is speaking. Fairtrade, the Accord and Baptist World Aid each report on their own work, so you ask four questions about any evidence: Who? Compared with what? How big? When?
A BTN story (24 August 2021, 3 min 42 sec) on the environmental side of fast fashion and what happens to clothes after we give them away. The lesson itself has no video; this is a refresher from L21 that shows why these strategies are needed. Preview before class.
The Accord and the Ethical Fashion Report are about safe work and fair pay for garment workers.
Fairtrade and brand grades try to make making and buying clothes more responsible.
Brands, unions, farmers, charities and shoppers have to work together for a strategy to succeed.
Goal icons: United Nations, used for illustrative/educational purposes. Click a goal to learn more at sdgs.un.org.
In September 2026, 300 garment brands and retailers had signed the International Accord, the highest number for any Accord agreement so far. Together they buy from more than 2,000 factories in Bangladesh and Pakistan.
Source: International Accord, 9 September 2026.
20 October 2026: Added 15/11 Baptist World Aid's 2026 Ethical Fashion Report graded 500 brands and found an average score of 31.5 out of 100, only a tiny improvement on 2024. Most companies (93 per cent) had policies on workers' rights, but the report's author said almost no garment worker in the supply chain is paid a living wage - evidence that a promise on paper is not the same as proof of change.
Source: ABC News, 20 October 2026, "Australian fashion ethical practices stalling, Baptist World Aid report finds."
15 September 2026: Added 15/11 Fairtrade International says a four-year project in Tamil Nadu, India, paid for by the European Union, reached more than 9,500 cotton farmers and 700 textile manufacturers before it ended on 15 September 2026. It reports that companies made 36 confirmed commitments to buy from Fairtrade cotton supply chains in India - a good chance to ask 'Who is speaking?', because this evidence comes from Fairtrade itself.
Source: Fairtrade International, 15 September 2026, "Four-Year EU Project Wraps Up After Advancing Sustainable Cotton and Textile Production in Tamil Nadu."
The International Accord was renewed in 2023 for three years, with automatic renewal for another three. In September 2026 it reported its highest number of signatories, 13 years after the Rana Plaza factory collapse in Bangladesh that led to the first Accord.
Source: International Accord, 9 September 2026.
Dhaka, Bangladesh - on 24 April 2013 the Rana Plaza building, which held garment factories, collapsed and killed at least 1,134 people. It is the reason the Accord exists, and why Bangladesh is at the centre of today's lesson.
Source: International Labour Organization, Bangladesh, Rana Plaza and beyond.
Factory safety inspector - checks garment factories for fire, electrical and building hazards, the work the Accord pays for.
Ethical sourcing manager - works for a clothing brand to find out who makes its products and whether workers are safe and fairly paid.
Judging a strategy with evidence is at the heart of senior Geography.
Stage 5: Environmental change and management: looks at strategies to manage environmental change and how to judge whether they work.
Stage 6 (HSC) - Year 11 People, patterns and processes; Year 12 Rural and urban places: asks you to explain and evaluate how people and organisations manage change in places, using evidence.